Pretty sure this is just because of the potion part of the item name, but it certainly isn't a special item.

Yeah I noticed that too. I keep getting excited over nothing. :x

that's because it's a rare only given out by that machine i believe

Naw, it restocks in the toy box. There was a couple in there just now actually.

@ noosky

sigh lemme go find the post that explains why it has the border [edit]

that's a quote from keith on the GA forums..

Well, the thing that concerns me is that this is the only red border I've seen and it's like putting Christmas lights on a cactus... still in spirit, but not the real thing.

It's a rarity 55 item that restocks in the toy box. It's not rare, nor exclusive. It's not hard to get at all. The quote doesn't explain why it should have a red box unless I'm missing some other context here. :x

Hmm, I'll look into this. It's possible it accidentally got added to the "rare items" of this machine which means anytime it vends normally (because it's pretty low rarity) it think its special. Taking a look!

Yup, this is all fixed now. Thank you guys!